== Progress ==
o Linaro GCC/Validation
* Continue releases handover
- Branch merges done
- Monthly snapshots about to be deployed
o LLVM
* Jira cards review
* Checked/updated cards related to upstream BZ
* Continue ramp-up
o Misc
* Various meetings and discussions.
== Plan ==
o Continue release handover and LLVM ramp-up
== This Week ==
* TCWG-1234 (5/10)
- Posted analysis upstream with a test-case.
- Have a workaround that disables hoisting when only single stmt is to
be hoisted.
- Investigating solution to limit distance between hoisted def. and it's uses.
* TCWG-1005 (2/10)
- Did changes based on upstream feedback from Honza, validated patch.
- Waiting for final approval from Honza before committing.
* Sick leave (2/10)
* Misc (1/10)
- Meetings
== Next Week ==
- TCWG-1234, TCWG-1005
* One day off after Connect
== Progress ==
o Linaro GCC/Validation
* Handover releases to ARM on-going.
o LLVM
* Continue ramp-up
o Misc
* Various meetings and discussions.
* Debrief Connect inside ST
== Plan ==
o Continue release handover
o LLVM Jira card: cleanup and find first tasks to do
== This Week ==
* TCWG-1234: code-hoisting regression (3/10)
- Have a workaround that fixes the particular regression (but may
introduce another)
- Trying to cross build benchmarks
- Investigating PRE and code-hoisting optimizations
* TCWG-1005: malloc attr propagation (3/10)
- Iteration based on upstream feedback.
* TCWG-1253 (1/10)
- Committed patch last week to add patterns for div and cmp against 0.
- Patch to transform rshift and cmp against 0 to cmp between operands
in upstream review.
* Public Holiday (2/10)
* Misc (1/10)
- Meetings
== Next Week ==
- TCWG-1234, TCWG-1005
== Connect ==
* Various discussions on GNU toolchain roadmap
== Progress ==
* GCC
- committed fix for PR71727 (strict-align bug on aarch64), backported
to gcc-7-branch
- small fixes in the testsuite
* GCC upstream validation:
- problems with internal infrastructure, but validation results OK
- reported a couple of regressions/new failures
- ran validations for a couple of tentative patches
- noise reduction: looking at how to report randomly killed processes
* misc (conf-calls, meetings, emails, ....)
- Connect feedback (internal)
== Next ==
* GCC upstream validation
* GCC/ubsan
* GCC/deprecated-IT blocks
# Progress #
* GDB SVE patches review. [4/10]
Finished my patches to remove the last use of MAX_REGISTER_SIZE. Send
them to Alan to review.
* GDB flexible target description follow-up. [4/10]
Committed some patches to improve GDB build, so that we can easily
share code of target description between GDB and GDBserver. Done.
* File Linaro Connect expense, and misc. [2/10]
# Plan #
* On holiday, Mon - Thu.
* Either GDB target description work,or ILP32 GDB branch.
--
Yao Qi
On 24 July 2017 at 18:38, Christophe Lyon <christophe.lyon(a)linaro.org> wrote:
>
>
> Le 24 juil. 2017 18:30, "Ard Biesheuvel" <ard.biesheuvel(a)linaro.org> a écrit
> :
>
> On 18 July 2017 at 13:54, Christophe Lyon <christophe.lyon(a)linaro.org>
> wrote:
>> On 13 July 2017 at 13:50, Christophe Lyon <christophe.lyon(a)linaro.org>
>> wrote:
>>> On 12 July 2017 at 19:33, Ard Biesheuvel <ard.biesheuvel(a)linaro.org>
>>> wrote:
>>>> On 12 July 2017 at 18:27, Alexei Fedorov <Alexei.Fedorov(a)arm.com> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> Christophe, Leif, Ard, Ryan at al.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> We are observing unaligned memory access fault with UEFI code compiled
>>>>> by
>>>>> Linaro GCC 6.3.1 & 7.1.1 using -O3 optimisation option.
>>>>>
>>>>> The fault occures at the very early stage of UEFI boot with MMU not
>>>>> being
>>>>> enabled yet.
>>>>>
>>>>> The failing function is CalculateSum8() from
>>>>> edk2\MdePkg\Library\BaseLib\CheckSum.c:
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> UINT8
>>>>> EFIAPI
>>>>> CalculateSum8 (
>>>>> IN CONST UINT8 *Buffer,
>>>>> IN UINTN Length
>>>>> )
>>>>> {
>>>>> UINT8 Sum;
>>>>> UINTN Count;
>>>>>
>>>>> ASSERT (Buffer != NULL);
>>>>> ASSERT (Length <= (MAX_ADDRESS - ((UINTN) Buffer) + 1));
>>>>>
>>>>> for (Sum = 0, Count = 0; Count < Length; Count++) {
>>>>> Sum = (UINT8) (Sum + *(Buffer + Count));
>>>>> }
>>>>>
>>>>> return Sum;
>>>>> }
>>>>>
>>>>> & the instruction which causes the exception is "ldr q1, [x1], 16"
>>>>> which
>>>>> accesses Buffer = 0xE0000048 pointed by X1 register, see the part of
>>>>> generated assembly code:
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> // r:\edk2\MdePkg\Library\BaseLib\CheckSum.c:49: for (Sum = 0, Count
>>>>> = 0;
>>>>> Count < Length; Count++) {
>>>>> .loc 1 49 0 is_stmt 1
>>>>> cbz x19, .L10 // Length,
>>>>> .L4:
>>>>> sub x0, x19, #1 // tmp150, Length,
>>>>> cmp x0, 14 // tmp150,
>>>>> bls .L11 //,
>>>>> // r:\edk2\MdePkg\Library\BaseLib\CheckSum.c:42: {
>>>>> .loc 1 42 0
>>>>> movi v0.4s, 0 // vect_Sum_19.24
>>>>> lsr x2, x19, 4 // bnd.18, Length,
>>>>> mov x1, x20 // ivtmp.29, Buffer
>>>>> mov x0, 0 // ivtmp.28,
>>>>> .LVL4:
>>>>> .p2align 3
>>>>> .L7:
>>>>> // r:\edk2\MdePkg\Library\BaseLib\CheckSum.c:50: Sum = (UINT8) (Sum
>>>>> +
>>>>> *(Buffer + Count));
>>>>> .loc 1 50 0 discriminator 3
>>>>> ldr q1, [x1], 16 // vect__6.23, MEM[(const UINT8
>>>>> *)vectp_Buffer.21_38]
>>>>> add x0, x0, 1 // ivtmp.28, ivtmp.28,
>>>>> cmp x0, x2 // ivtmp.28, bnd.18
>>>>> add v0.16b, v0.16b, v1.16b // vect_Sum_19.24, vect_Sum_19.24,
>>>>> vect__6.23
>>>>> bcc .L7 //,
>>>>>
>>>>> ...
>>>>>
>>>>> Although all AARCH64 code is compiled with "-mstrict-align" option
>>>>> which
>>>>> according to GCC 3.18.1 AArch64 Options:
>>>>>
>>>>> "-mstrict-align
>>>>>
>>>>> Avoid generating memory accesses that may not be aligned on a natural
>>>>> object
>>>>> boundary as described in the architecture specification."
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> the generated code doesn't comply with this description. In this case
>>>>> X1 =
>>>>> Buffer @0xE0000048 and is not aligned to 16 bytes boundary.
>>>>>
>>>>> The similiar code is generated by GCC 6.3.1-2017.05 but 5.3.1-2016.05
>>>>> compiler produces only 16 bytes aligned memory accesses when loading Q1
>>>>> register.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> I attached the simple test file which can be compiled by running GCC
>>>>> compilation with
>>>>>
>>>>> -c test.c -O3 -mstrict-align -save-temps
>>>>>
>>>>> to see the difference between code generated by 7.1.1 & 5.3.1 GCC
>>>>> versions.
>>>>>
>>>>> It seems that 5.3.1 ignores "-mstrict-align" option at all and always
>>>>> generates aligned pointers for loading Q1 register, 7.1.1 & 6.3.1 also
>>>>> ignore the option but generate slighly different code with unaligned
>>>>> access
>>>>> enabled.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Please share your thoughts regading this issue.
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Hello Alexei,
>>>>
>>>> This does look like a compiler bug to me. 'Buffer' is a pointer to
>>>> unsigned char, and so the compiler should never emit the ldr
>>>> instruction under -mstrict-align.
>>>>
>>>> In the mean time, we could work around this with adding
>>>> -mgeneral-regs-only in all places where -mstrict-align is being
>>>> passed. In general, I don't really see the point of supporting the use
>>>> of FP/ASIMD registers in UEFI beyond ensuring that our builds are
>>>> compatible with 3rd party binaries that do use them.
>>>>
>>>
>>> Hello Alexei,
>>>
>>> I agree with Ard: it looks like a compiler bug, I'm looking at it.
>>>
>>> And indeed in the mean time, using -mgeneral-regs-only should
>>> workaround your problem.
>>>
>>
>> Hello,
>>
>> As a follow-up, I've posted a patch:
>> https://gcc.gnu.org/ml/gcc-patches/2017-07/msg01063.html
>>
>> We'll see if maintainers agree.
>>
>
> Thanks. By the looks of it, nobody cared to respond, right?
>
>
> Not yet and we are used to slow response.
>
> In addition I'm on holidays until Aug 21st so I won't ping until then.
>
>
Hi all,
My patch was finally accepted last week and committed.
I also backported it to the gcc-7-branch, so that the problem will
be fixed in the next gcc-7 release (either FSF or Linaro).
Thanks,
Christophe
# Progress #
* Flexible GDB target description work. [5/10]
As we'll add more and more files, need to clean up GDB build first.
Patch is OK, but need to reduce the duplication first. Yet another
clean up.
Start to think about the design of removing last usage of
MAX_REGISTER_SIZE. Still ongoing.
* Misc, [5/10]
** File cauldron expense.
** Improve gdb_mbuild.sh to build GDB for different supported targets.
# Plan #
* Connect.
--
Yao Qi
