Thanks for letting me know. I could use some help to repro because I'm not very familiar with that benchmark or ARM32. 1. Can you provide the unoptimized IR for "BZ2_decompress"? 2. What is the particular flavor/CPU of ARM32 to target? 3. Was there a speed regression in addition to the size regression?
If you can file a bugzilla with any of this, that would be best of course. That way, we can pull in ARM or other experts as needed if this is a codegen issue or problem with another IR pass.
On Wed, Jul 14, 2021 at 10:55 AM Maxim Kuvyrkov maxim.kuvyrkov@linaro.org wrote:
Hi Sanjay,
On 32-bit ARM your patch appears to increase code size of BZ2_decompress from SPEC2006’s 401.bzip2 by 50% — from 7.5K to 11K. This increases overall code size of 401.bzip2 benchmark by 10%.
Would you please investigate?
Please let us know if you need help reproducing the problem.
Regards,
-- Maxim Kuvyrkov https://www.linaro.org
On 14 Jul 2021, at 17:32, ci_notify@linaro.org wrote:
Successfully identified regression in *llvm* in CI configuration
tcwg_bmk_llvm_tk1/llvm-master-arm-spec2k6-Os. So far, this commit has regressed CI configurations:
- tcwg_bmk_llvm_tk1/llvm-master-arm-spec2k6-Os
Culprit:
<cut> commit 40b752d28d95158e52dba7cfeea92e41b7ccff9a Author: Sanjay Patel <spatel@rotateright.com> Date: Mon Jul 5 09:57:39 2021 -0400
[InstCombine] fold icmp slt/sgt of offset value with constant
This follows up patches for the unsigned siblings: 0c400e895306 c7b658aeb526
We are translating an offset signed compare to its unsigned equivalent when one end of the range is at the limit (zero or unsigned max).
(X + C2) >s C --> X <u (SMAX - C) (if C == C2 - 1) (X + C2) <s C --> X >u (C ^ SMAX) (if C == C2)
This probably does not show up much in IR derived from C/C++ source because that would likely have 'nsw', and we have folds for that already.
As with the previous unsigned transforms, the folds could be generalized to handle non-constant patterns:
https://alive2.llvm.org/ce/z/Y8Xrrm
; sgt define i1 @src(i8 %a, i8 %c) { %c2 = add i8 %c, 1 %t = add i8 %a, %c2 %ov = icmp sgt i8 %t, %c ret i1 %ov } define i1 @tgt(i8 %a, i8 %c) { %c_off = sub i8 127, %c ; SMAX %ov = icmp ult i8 %a, %c_off ret i1 %ov }https://alive2.llvm.org/ce/z/c8uhnk
; slt define i1 @src(i8 %a, i8 %c) { %t = add i8 %a, %c %ov = icmp slt i8 %t, %c ret i1 %ov } define i1 @tgt(i8 %a, i8 %c) { %c_offnot = xor i8 %c, 127 ; SMAX %ov = icmp ugt i8 %a, %c_offnot ret i1 %ov }</cut>
Results regressed to (for first_bad ==
40b752d28d95158e52dba7cfeea92e41b7ccff9a)
# reset_artifacts: -10 # build_abe binutils: -9 # build_abe stage1 -- --set gcc_override_configure=--with-mode=thumb
--set gcc_override_configure=--disable-libsanitizer:
-8 # build_abe linux: -7 # build_abe glibc: -6 # build_abe stage2 -- --set gcc_override_configure=--with-mode=thumb
--set gcc_override_configure=--disable-libsanitizer:
-5 # build_llvm true: -3 # true: 0 # benchmark -Os_mthumb --
artifacts/build-40b752d28d95158e52dba7cfeea92e41b7ccff9a/results_id:
1 # 401.bzip2,bzip2_base.default
regressed by 110
# 401.bzip2,[.] BZ2_decompress
regressed by 149
from (for last_good == 32dd914f7182875730eb3453f39dcc584b7219b2) # reset_artifacts: -10 # build_abe binutils: -9 # build_abe stage1 -- --set gcc_override_configure=--with-mode=thumb
--set gcc_override_configure=--disable-libsanitizer:
-8 # build_abe linux: -7 # build_abe glibc: -6 # build_abe stage2 -- --set gcc_override_configure=--with-mode=thumb
--set gcc_override_configure=--disable-libsanitizer:
-5 # build_llvm true: -3 # true: 0 # benchmark -Os_mthumb --
artifacts/build-32dd914f7182875730eb3453f39dcc584b7219b2/results_id:
1
Artifacts of last_good build:
https://ci.linaro.org/job/tcwg_bmk_ci_llvm-bisect-tcwg_bmk_tk1-llvm-master-a...
Results ID of last_good:
tk1_32/tcwg_bmk_llvm_tk1/bisect-llvm-master-arm-spec2k6-Os/1631
Artifacts of first_bad build:
https://ci.linaro.org/job/tcwg_bmk_ci_llvm-bisect-tcwg_bmk_tk1-llvm-master-a...
Results ID of first_bad:
tk1_32/tcwg_bmk_llvm_tk1/bisect-llvm-master-arm-spec2k6-Os/1622
Build top page/logs:
https://ci.linaro.org/job/tcwg_bmk_ci_llvm-bisect-tcwg_bmk_tk1-llvm-master-a...
Configuration details:
Reproduce builds:
<cut> mkdir investigate-llvm-40b752d28d95158e52dba7cfeea92e41b7ccff9a cd investigate-llvm-40b752d28d95158e52dba7cfeea92e41b7ccff9a
git clone https://git.linaro.org/toolchain/jenkins-scripts
mkdir -p artifacts/manifests curl -o artifacts/manifests/build-baseline.sh
https://ci.linaro.org/job/tcwg_bmk_ci_llvm-bisect-tcwg_bmk_tk1-llvm-master-a... --fail
curl -o artifacts/manifests/build-parameters.sh
https://ci.linaro.org/job/tcwg_bmk_ci_llvm-bisect-tcwg_bmk_tk1-llvm-master-a... --fail
curl -o artifacts/test.sh
https://ci.linaro.org/job/tcwg_bmk_ci_llvm-bisect-tcwg_bmk_tk1-llvm-master-a... --fail
chmod +x artifacts/test.sh
# Reproduce the baseline build (build all pre-requisites) ./jenkins-scripts/tcwg_bmk-build.sh @@
artifacts/manifests/build-baseline.sh
# Save baseline build state (which is then restored in artifacts/test.sh) rsync -a --del --delete-excluded --exclude bisect/ --exclude artifacts/
--exclude llvm/ ./ ./bisect/baseline/
cd llvm
# Reproduce first_bad build git checkout --detach 40b752d28d95158e52dba7cfeea92e41b7ccff9a ../artifacts/test.sh
# Reproduce last_good build git checkout --detach 32dd914f7182875730eb3453f39dcc584b7219b2 ../artifacts/test.sh
cd ..
</cut>
History of pending regressions and results:
https://git.linaro.org/toolchain/ci/base-artifacts.git/log/?h=linaro-local/c...
Artifacts:
https://ci.linaro.org/job/tcwg_bmk_ci_llvm-bisect-tcwg_bmk_tk1-llvm-master-a...
Build log:
https://ci.linaro.org/job/tcwg_bmk_ci_llvm-bisect-tcwg_bmk_tk1-llvm-master-a...
Full commit (up to 1000 lines):
<cut> commit 40b752d28d95158e52dba7cfeea92e41b7ccff9a Author: Sanjay Patel <spatel@rotateright.com> Date: Mon Jul 5 09:57:39 2021 -0400
[InstCombine] fold icmp slt/sgt of offset value with constant
This follows up patches for the unsigned siblings: 0c400e895306 c7b658aeb526
We are translating an offset signed compare to its unsigned equivalent when one end of the range is at the limit (zero or unsigned max).
(X + C2) >s C --> X <u (SMAX - C) (if C == C2 - 1) (X + C2) <s C --> X >u (C ^ SMAX) (if C == C2)
This probably does not show up much in IR derived from C/C++ source because that would likely have 'nsw', and we have folds for that already.
As with the previous unsigned transforms, the folds could be generalized to handle non-constant patterns:
https://alive2.llvm.org/ce/z/Y8Xrrm
; sgt define i1 @src(i8 %a, i8 %c) { %c2 = add i8 %c, 1 %t = add i8 %a, %c2 %ov = icmp sgt i8 %t, %c ret i1 %ov } define i1 @tgt(i8 %a, i8 %c) { %c_off = sub i8 127, %c ; SMAX %ov = icmp ult i8 %a, %c_off ret i1 %ov }https://alive2.llvm.org/ce/z/c8uhnk
; slt define i1 @src(i8 %a, i8 %c) { %t = add i8 %a, %c %ov = icmp slt i8 %t, %c ret i1 %ov } define i1 @tgt(i8 %a, i8 %c) { %c_offnot = xor i8 %c, 127 ; SMAX %ov = icmp ugt i8 %a, %c_offnot ret i1 %ov }
.../Transforms/InstCombine/InstCombineCompares.cpp | 21
++++++++++++++-------
llvm/test/Transforms/InstCombine/icmp-add.ll | 20
++++++++++----------
2 files changed, 24 insertions(+), 17 deletions(-)
diff --git a/llvm/lib/Transforms/InstCombine/InstCombineCompares.cpp
b/llvm/lib/Transforms/InstCombine/InstCombineCompares.cpp
index 6bd479def210..6e66c61f5e46 100644 --- a/llvm/lib/Transforms/InstCombine/InstCombineCompares.cpp +++ b/llvm/lib/Transforms/InstCombine/InstCombineCompares.cpp @@ -2636,20 +2636,27 @@ Instruction
*InstCombinerImpl::foldICmpAddConstant(ICmpInst &Cmp,
// Fold icmp pred (add X, C2), C. Value *X = Add->getOperand(0); Type *Ty = Add->getType();
- CmpInst::Predicate Pred = Cmp.getPredicate();
- const CmpInst::Predicate Pred = Cmp.getPredicate();
- const APInt SMax =
APInt::getSignedMaxValue(Ty->getScalarSizeInBits());
- const APInt SMin =
APInt::getSignedMinValue(Ty->getScalarSizeInBits());
- // Fold an unsigned compare with offset to signed compare:
- // Fold compare with offset to opposite sign compare if it eliminates
offset:
// (X + C2) >u C --> X <s -C2 (if C == C2 + SMAX)
- // TODO: Find the signed predicate siblings.
- if (Pred == CmpInst::ICMP_UGT &&
C == *C2 + APInt::getSignedMaxValue(Ty->getScalarSizeInBits()))
- if (Pred == CmpInst::ICMP_UGT && C == *C2 + SMax) return new ICmpInst(ICmpInst::ICMP_SLT, X, ConstantInt::get(Ty,
-(*C2)));
// (X + C2) <u C --> X >s ~C2 (if C == C2 + SMIN)
- if (Pred == CmpInst::ICMP_ULT &&
C == *C2 + APInt::getSignedMinValue(Ty->getScalarSizeInBits()))
- if (Pred == CmpInst::ICMP_ULT && C == *C2 + SMin) return new ICmpInst(ICmpInst::ICMP_SGT, X, ConstantInt::get(Ty,
~(*C2)));
- // (X + C2) >s C --> X <u (SMAX - C) (if C == C2 - 1)
- if (Pred == CmpInst::ICMP_SGT && C == *C2 - 1)
- return new ICmpInst(ICmpInst::ICMP_ULT, X, ConstantInt::get(Ty,
SMax - C));
- // (X + C2) <s C --> X >u (C ^ SMAX) (if C == C2)
- if (Pred == CmpInst::ICMP_SLT && C == *C2)
- return new ICmpInst(ICmpInst::ICMP_UGT, X, ConstantInt::get(Ty, C ^
SMax));
- // If the add does not wrap, we can always adjust the compare by
subtracting
// the constants. Equality comparisons are handled elsewhere.
SGE/SLE/UGE/ULE
// are canonicalized to SGT/SLT/UGT/ULT. diff --git a/llvm/test/Transforms/InstCombine/icmp-add.ll
b/llvm/test/Transforms/InstCombine/icmp-add.ll
index 1f00dc6e2992..aa69325d716c 100644 --- a/llvm/test/Transforms/InstCombine/icmp-add.ll +++ b/llvm/test/Transforms/InstCombine/icmp-add.ll @@ -842,8 +842,7 @@ define i1 @ult_wrong_offset(i8 %a) {
define i1 @sgt_offset(i8 %a) { ; CHECK-LABEL: @sgt_offset( -; CHECK-NEXT: [[T:%.*]] = add i8 [[A:%.*]], -6 -; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp sgt i8 [[T]], -7 +; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp ult i8 [[A:%.*]], -122 ; CHECK-NEXT: ret i1 [[OV]] ; %t = add i8 %a, -6 @@ -855,7 +854,7 @@ define i1 @sgt_offset_use(i32 %a) { ; CHECK-LABEL: @sgt_offset_use( ; CHECK-NEXT: [[T:%.*]] = add i32 [[A:%.*]], 42 ; CHECK-NEXT: call void @use(i32 [[T]]) -; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp sgt i32 [[T]], 41 +; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp ult i32 [[A]], 2147483606 ; CHECK-NEXT: ret i1 [[OV]] ; %t = add i32 %a, 42 @@ -866,8 +865,7 @@ define i1 @sgt_offset_use(i32 %a) {
define <2 x i1> @sgt_offset_splat(<2 x i5> %a) { ; CHECK-LABEL: @sgt_offset_splat( -; CHECK-NEXT: [[T:%.*]] = add <2 x i5> [[A:%.*]], <i5 9, i5 9> -; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp sgt <2 x i5> [[T]], <i5 8, i5 8> +; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp ult <2 x i5> [[A:%.*]], <i5 7, i5 7> ; CHECK-NEXT: ret <2 x i1> [[OV]] ; %t = add <2 x i5> %a, <i5 9, i5 9> @@ -875,6 +873,8 @@ define <2 x i1> @sgt_offset_splat(<2 x i5> %a) { ret <2 x i1> %ov }
+; negative test - constants must differ by 1
define i1 @sgt_wrong_offset(i8 %a) { ; CHECK-LABEL: @sgt_wrong_offset( ; CHECK-NEXT: [[T:%.*]] = add i8 [[A:%.*]], -7 @@ -888,8 +888,7 @@ define i1 @sgt_wrong_offset(i8 %a) {
define i1 @slt_offset(i8 %a) { ; CHECK-LABEL: @slt_offset( -; CHECK-NEXT: [[T:%.*]] = add i8 [[A:%.*]], -6 -; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp slt i8 [[T]], -6 +; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp ugt i8 [[A:%.*]], -123 ; CHECK-NEXT: ret i1 [[OV]] ; %t = add i8 %a, -6 @@ -901,7 +900,7 @@ define i1 @slt_offset_use(i32 %a) { ; CHECK-LABEL: @slt_offset_use( ; CHECK-NEXT: [[T:%.*]] = add i32 [[A:%.*]], 42 ; CHECK-NEXT: call void @use(i32 [[T]]) -; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp slt i32 [[T]], 42 +; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp ugt i32 [[A]], 2147483605 ; CHECK-NEXT: ret i1 [[OV]] ; %t = add i32 %a, 42 @@ -912,8 +911,7 @@ define i1 @slt_offset_use(i32 %a) {
define <2 x i1> @slt_offset_splat(<2 x i5> %a) { ; CHECK-LABEL: @slt_offset_splat( -; CHECK-NEXT: [[T:%.*]] = add <2 x i5> [[A:%.*]], <i5 9, i5 9> -; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp slt <2 x i5> [[T]], <i5 9, i5 9> +; CHECK-NEXT: [[OV:%.*]] = icmp ugt <2 x i5> [[A:%.*]], <i5 6, i5 6> ; CHECK-NEXT: ret <2 x i1> [[OV]] ; %t = add <2 x i5> %a, <i5 9, i5 9> @@ -921,6 +919,8 @@ define <2 x i1> @slt_offset_splat(<2 x i5> %a) { ret <2 x i1> %ov }
+; negative test - constants must be equal
define i1 @slt_wrong_offset(i8 %a) { ; CHECK-LABEL: @slt_wrong_offset( ; CHECK-NEXT: [[T:%.*]] = add i8 [[A:%.*]], -6
</cut>